6 measurable benefits of 1:1 staff coaching for student support teams

‍Individualized higher education professional development that transforms measurable student outcomes

Higher education institutions are under more pressure than ever to deliver measurable student outcomes, mitigate the cost of advisor turnover and enhance the student journey. Our Coaching Development and Training programs show that stronger staff coaching and development leads to more effective student interactions — increasing learner persistence and completion. 

That's why participants in InsideTrack Certification programs are paired with a Professional Development (PD) Consultant who provides personalized, one-on-one coaching throughout their entire certification journey. We teamed up with our PD team to share six insights and observations on how coaching sessions build staff capacity and transform student outcomes.

‍

Table of contents

1. Deepening staff confidence
2. Elevating communication 
3. Cultivating student agency
4. Sharpening core competencies 
5. Mitigating staff burnout 
6. Reclaiming advisor time 

‍

1. Deepening staff confidence to positively drive student trajectories

For student supporters to catalyze student success, they need to feel confident in their ability to make a meaningful impact. One-on-one development sessions build confidence by:

• Providing a reliable framework for student interactions, allowing staff to have more purpose-filled meetings that help students move toward meaningful action.
• Demonstrating success strategies like role statements, transparency and the CLEAR framework for building student self-efficacy and agency. These tools also assist staff in navigating difficult discussions with their students.
• Offering a supportive environment for hands-on practice and feedback with direct observation and collaborative debriefing. 
• Showing student supporters that it’s okay to put students in the driver’s seat, letting them lead the problem-solving with their coach as a guide. 

Building staff confidence in this way is transformative for bandwidth and morale. As Dr. Melody Duckins, PD Consultant at InsideTrack, recalls of a certification participant: "He initially lacked trust that his students could solve their own problems. His intentions were good, but coaching helped him realize that he was enabling them. Throughout our sessions, we focused on centering on the learner and reframing his role as a guide."

By experiencing personalized guidance themselves, staff members learn that effective coaching doesn't require adopting a rigid persona. Instead, they can bring their authentic selves to every interaction.

"My coach, Stacy, gave me confidence and guidance to finish the certification program strong. We celebrated my past wins and she helped me plan how I will pass the next section. The coaching and guidance provided by Stacy is second to none. I benefited greatly from our meetings and have nothing but the highest praise for her."
‍
— InsideTrack Coaching Certification Participant 

‍

2. Elevating communication to increase student engagement and trust

Many student supporters possess a natural gift for connecting with people, but translating those skills into consistent, trust-building interactions requires practice. One-on-one development sessions with the InsideTrack PD team help institutional staff take their communication to the next level by introducing key tools for scaling academic advising and improving student success metrics, including:

• Framing
• Role articulation
• Setting explicit meeting intentions

This establishes emotional safety from the beginning, helping learners feel comfortable and supported. As InsideTrack PD Consultant Jen Adams explains, “Sharing what the desired outcome or intention is of the meeting makes a big difference in setting the stage and providing a learner with comfort from the start. This allows them to know what to expect and how to engage in the relationship and conversations moving forward.”

Once a foundation of trust is in place, development sessions help staff shift from a directive, instructional approach toward open-ended questioning. By leaning into curiosity and utilizing assessment tools, student supporters learn to eliminate assumptions and check in before tackling sensitive topics.

"I’ve been using framing and assessing in all of my meetings. I can see the impact for the students, too. By using transparency to reiterate my role, the learner felt more comfortable sharing about his situation. The impact for me is that it gives me the opportunity to dive deeper and ask more questions in order to help students achieve their goals with clarity and direction." 
‍
— Josee Sayaloune, Retention Specialist in the Office of Academic Success, Chadron State College

‍

3. Shifting from problem-solving to cultivating student agency

Transitioning from a reactive problem-solver to a facilitator of student agency is one of the most challenging shifts student supporters undergo. Of this mindset change, Terrell Henry, Reentry Coordinator at Carteret Community College, says, “Instead of putting out every fire myself, I want to give everyone their own extinguisher.” One-on-one development sessions help staff navigate this transition by:

• Giving staff dedicated space to pause, examine default habits and address limiting beliefs that can lead to burnout
• Modeling open-ended questioning so staff can experience this developmental approach firsthand and replicate it with learners
• Expanding institutional capacity by reducing reliance on constant, reactive emergency interventions
• Driving student retention strategies by positioning student agency as a scalability lever that builds essential knowledge, skills and beliefs

Releasing the burden of fixing every issue creates a more collaborative, high-impact dynamic. As Henry Appy, PD Consultant at InsideTrack, notes: "I find that coaches are often relieved to realize that they don’t always have to solve every problem — it can be incredibly freeing to take that pressure off, and ultimately, the impact of coaching becomes greater when the relationship is more collaborative and developmental."

“This isn’t about me. This is about the student. I had to let go of the idea that they are children. I told myself that learners need to keep learning; therefore, each interaction needs to be a teachable moment for both myself and the learner. Before, I didn’t have the tools to make this possible. Now I do.” 

— Kelvin J. Harris, Sr. Director, Student Services & Scholarship Operations, UNCF

‍

4. Sharpening core coaching competencies through practice and thoughtful reinforcement

Translating theories into daily student interactions requires space for staff to practice and adapt to their specific roles. These sessions strengthen core competencies for staff by:

• Debriefing real-world student interactions in a supportive, low-stakes environment
• Providing personalized practice through methods like call recording reviews, visual diagrams and live role-plays
• Modeling coaching skills directly so staff experience the tools and techniques they will use with learners

This approach allows staff to test specific language and build confidence step by step, Kate Mills, PD Consultant at InsideTrack, explains. Feedback during coaching sessions is crucial in sharpening core competencies for student supporters: “We really tailor our 1:1 development sessions to what the participant needs and what their ideal learning style is. We really practice what we preach — so they’re getting personalized examples of coaching in action," she adds. 

“What I valued most about my InsideTrack experience was how feedback was always framed with care. My coach highlighted what was working well before pointing out areas for growth, and I’ve started using that same approach with my team and even with my daughters. ‘Areas of opportunity’ has become one of my new buzz phrases.” 

— InsideTrack Coaching Certification Participant

‍

5. Mitigating staff burnout to reduce turnover and expand support capacity

Higher education institutions are facing unprecedented staff capacity constraints, leaving student support teams stretched thin as they struggle to manage heavy caseloads and combat higher ed advisor burnout. When InsideTrack PD consultants target advisor turnover reduction through development sessions, student supporters gain the tools to navigate daily stress and restore their energy. This is often achieved by:

• Streamlining interactions so staff can prioritize core topics without carrying the full conversational load.
• Handing problem-solving back to students to prevent staff exhaustion and make support more sustainable. As one training participant said, "I feel more whole than I did at the beginning of this training."
• Connecting daily student support tasks back to personal values and core motivations to maintain focus on long-term impact.

When staff set healthy boundaries and shift away from a purely instructional role, the sense of relief is immediate. Adams shares an anecdote from working with a higher ed staff member: "After learning about the concept of taking on a developmental, rather than instructional, student support approach, they said it felt 'liberating' because it took the pressure off of them to have all the answers."

"Coaching has made me better at my job. It allows me to let the students make more choices for themselves and become a little more independent faster. It decreases my stress load because I do not always have to be so instructional."

— InsideTrack Coaching Certification Participant

‍

For a dedicated tool on expanding staff capacity, download our "Essential Retention Toolkit," which explores how equipping staff with tangible coaching strategies fuels student retention. 

‍

6. Reclaiming advisor time for strategic planning and sustainable long-term impact

In the fast-paced higher ed environment, having a dedicated partner can make all the difference. One-on-one development sessions give staff and higher ed leaders a rare, supportive environment to step away from daily operations and truly evaluate their practice. InsideTrack Coaching helps student supporters unlock time for strategic reflection and long-term planning by:

• Offering a space to process challenges and approach student support with a refreshed mindset
• Connecting daily decisions back to personal values, team goals and overarching institutional goals
• Providing reflective support for staff in under-resourced or high-turnover settings 

This reflection is crucial. As Colleen Arrey, PD Consultant at InsideTrack, notes: "One-on-one sessions are some of the only times our partner staff get to reflect and plan in a supportive environment with a neutral party helping them to navigate challenges. Stopping to reflect on alignment and vision can have a powerful impact on how a participant approaches projects, relationships, campus politics — everything."

"InsideTrack has truly changed the way I work with students by helping me approach each interaction with more purpose and intention. Moving forward, I want to continue refining my practice and strengthening my ability to consistently apply the model. To hold myself accountable, I plan to schedule an ongoing bi-weekly learning session with myself so I can continue developing my skills and keep the coaching framework at the forefront of my daily work."

— InsideTrack Coaching Certification Participant

‍

Pursue capacity building to train and develop your staff and scale student impact

Investing in individualized professional development gives your student supporters the confidence, practical tools and reflective space needed to thrive in their roles. Grounded in our evidence-based methodology, this approach can empower your higher ed staff to create a sustainable culture of support that directly drives stronger student persistence and completion across campus. Our extensive research explains how success coaching improves student outcomes.

‍

From time to time, we tap into the expertise of our InsideTrack team and ask them to share insights on a student support topic they’re passionate about. This week, we interviewed the InsideTrack Professional Development team to share their perspective on how one-on-one professional development for student support staff helps them expand their capacity, lead more effective meetings and ultimately deliver stronger student outcomes. Special thanks to the entire Professional Development team: Jen Adams, Henry Appy, Colleen Arrey, Stacy Counterman, Dr. Melody Duckins, Linda Firth, Arwen Foster, Zhane McClyde, Keenan Medley and Kate Mills.

‍